About Us | Submit an Ad/Contact Us | Subscribe | Commercial Printing
Cloudy 25°5 Day Forecast
Home : News : Local News : St. Clair News
Clay Reoffered Three-Year Deal Child Death Case
By: Nathan Woodside, St. Clair Missourian Editor
10/21/2009
email this storyEmail to a friendpost a commentPost a Commentprinter friendlyPrinter-friendly
Two weeks after a Franklin County judge rejected a plea deal that would put a man accused in the 2003 death of a St. Clair infant in jail for three years, the punishment may stick.

On Monday, Oct. 4, Judge Gael Wood rejected a deal that would have sentenced Larry D. Clay Jr. to three years in the department of corrections for the involuntary manslaughter of 15 1/2-month-old Macayla Carpenter.

This week Circuit Court Judge John Berkemeyer was assigned to handle a new trial, but Prosecutor Bob Parks offered Clay the same deal Wood rejected.

Parks said he expects Burkemeyer to accept the deal during a sentencing scheduled for Friday morning in Union.

The deal would give Clay credit for the time he's served in Franklin County Jail, which is more than a year. He would serve the rest of the three years in the Department of Corrections.

For Miranda Carpenter, the mother of Macayla, it's been a nightmarish roller coaster ride of emotions that has lasted nearly six years.

Carpenter has been vocal and relentless in her message that three years in the death of her daughter isn't enough.

When Judge Wood rejected the deal, offered to Clay earlier this summer, Carpenter felt like she had won a moral victory.

"I was so ecstatic at the thought of that plea deal being turned down," she said. "I was never willing to take no for an answer... Then I find out after it's been rejected, it's been offered again. I don't know what to say... I'm shaking so bad. I'm flabbergasted and sick. It's disgusting."

Carpenter said she was told by prosecutors that after Judge Wood rejected the first deal, they wouldn't reoffer the same deal again.

Parks said that wasn't the case whatsoever.

"Nobody ever promised that," he said.

Parks said he feels the plea deal is the right decision.

According to Parks, there is no eyewitness, which would make a murder conviction difficult.

At the time of the death, another child was present, but their testimony has been ruled inadmissible in court because of the child's young age.

Parks said a trial would have come down to dissenting opinions from medical examiners representing each council.

"Based on the evidence that we had, we offered a plea deal that we could have proven in court," Parks said. "... we did not believe that we could convict on the murder (in the second degree charge) and we wanted a conviction in this case. I thought it was best to do this plea deal."

Background
According to St. Clair Police Department records, officers responded to East Ridge Apartments at 5:30 p.m. on Dec. 1, 2003, in reference to a report of a small child not breathing.

Upon arrival, officers observed a neighbor performing CPR on Macayla, who was later transported to St. John's Mercy Hospital, Washington, where she was pronounced dead.

At the time of the incident, police say Clay was baby-sitting Macayla and her 4-year-old sister while Miranda was at work in Gerald.

Miranda told police she returned from work four hours later after leaving the children alone with Clay and found that Macayla wasn't breathing.

An autopsy later revealed the child died as a result of closed head trauma. Her death was classified as a homicide, records state.


©Washington Missouri 2010

Submit your comment now
Comment Title:
Submit your comments on the article in the space below:
Your Name:
Your City & State:  
Your Email Address: (required)
What's This?
In order to verify you are not a spam-bot you will need to use the image above.
The addition of the flashing numbers above =
By submitting your comment, you acknowledge that you have read and accept the Terms and Conditions of this site.
Reader Comments
Added: Friday October 23, 2009 at 05:34 PM EST
To watching..
he took an Alford Plea. Meaning he admits they had enough evidence to convict him, but still says he is innocent. My kid's sperm donor recently made an Alford plea for domestic assault and got 5 yrs. And his wife is alive and kickin
Angry in St. Clair, Saint Clair
Added: Friday October 23, 2009 at 04:00 PM EST
Maybe he doesnt have enough evidence on the wrong person. I for one took care of the child in question and her sister for one afternoon and saw several bruises on the child before the mother ever even met Mr. Clay. I think this is a matter of The white girl taking her child abuse too far and blaming it on the black guy.
Annonymous, st. louis mo
Added: Friday October 23, 2009 at 07:23 AM EST
Big JOKE
This is disgusting. PLEA BARGAN BOB strikes again. Not enough evidence to CONVICT. Then maybe the guy is INNOCENT. The victim of an over zelous prosecutor. Maybe he is guilty. He deserves a trail reguardless. TAKE HIM TO TRIAL BOB!! or are you afraid you'll LOSE because you are incompentant. Maybe by the time this thing actually goes to trial in 5 years we will have a better prosecutor in office. Or maybe the stress of 5 years of being put on hold will get to this guy too just like that assault case you were dragging your feet on.
Michael Banks, washington Mo
Added: Thursday October 22, 2009 at 07:17 PM EST
Who is watching your children
Did anyone ever stop to think they might not have enough evidence to get a conviction, once this goes in front of a jury? Well this looks like that kind of case.. I am glad this worthless person is going to prison, he could be found not guilty, if there is doubt.. In addition, this Larry Clay, Jr. has a past criminal history, I would not have left him in the care of my fish let alone my child! This Mother also needs to take responsibility for leaving her children in his care, her poor choice of a caregiver is sickening and very irresponsible. This child deserved so much better.
Nancy, washington
View All 8 Comments »

email this storyEmail to a friendpost a commentPost a Commentprinter friendlyPrinter-friendlyTop

Today's Most Read
 
Site Map

Local News
Home
Top Stories
Washington
Union
St. Clair
Pacific
Warren County Record

More News
Sports
Business
Death News, Obituaries
Legal Notices
My Mo Youth
Senior LifeTimes
Franklin County Hall of Honor

Photo Galleries
News
Sports
Artistic
Photos by You

Features, People
Feature Stories
Weddings, Births, Engagements
Missourian In Education

Opinion
Editorials
Letters to the Editor
Online Extras
Email Updates
This Week's Events
Links to Community Web Sites
Local Church Directory
Weather
Fun and Games

Advertising
Classifieds
Yellow Pages
Shop Our Ads
Classified Line Ad Submissions
Garage Sale Ad Submissions

About Us
Who We Are
How to Advertise
Subscription Information
Missourian Vendors
Commercial Printing
Contact Us


For general questions about the website, write to webmaster@emissourian.com
Copyright © 2008 The Missourian Publishing Company. All Rights Reserved.
Copyright © 1995 - 2010 www.emissourian.com All Rights Reserved.